St Nicholas School offers a calm, purposeful alternative to the pressure-cooker environment of many commuter-belt independent schools. Located in Old Harlow, the school occupies a 14-acre site where the Grade II listed Hillingdon House sits alongside modern teaching blocks. It is a co-educational day school for children aged 2 to 16, providing a seamless journey from the "Rocking Horse" nursery through to GCSEs.
The school is defined by its grounded atmosphere. While academic standards are high—consistently topping local performance tables—the culture is distinctly supportive rather than sharp-elbowed. Mr Terence Ayres, who was appointed Headmaster in April 2022, has reinforced this ethos. His leadership focuses on producing well-rounded, resilient young people, evidenced by the school's specific "River of Life" pastoral curriculum.
Parents choose St Nicholas for its ability to balance rigour with character. It suits families who want the facilities and class sizes of the independent sector but prefer a school that feels like a community rather than an institution.
Drive through the gates on Hobbs Cross Road and the noise of the M11 fades, replaced by the greenery of the Essex countryside. The campus feels expansive but contained, safe for the youngest pupils while offering enough space for teenagers to feel independent.
The atmosphere is noticeably friendly. This is a school where older pupils high-five the younger ones, a benefit of the all-through structure. The house system acts as the social glue, with competitions in sport, music, and debating ensuring that year groups mix naturally.
Unusually for a school of this type, it ends at Year 11. There is no Sixth Form. Far from being a drawback, the school frames this as a strength; it allows Year 11 students to be the undisputed leaders of the school, taking on prefect roles and responsibilities that might otherwise go to 18-year-olds. It also means the school is purely focused on the developmental needs of children up to age 16, without the distraction of young adults on site.
Academically, St Nicholas is the strongest performing school in the Harlow area. In 2024, the school achieved a proprietary FindMySchool ranking of 689th in England for GCSE outcomes. This places it in the "national strong" band, comfortably outperforming the vast majority of schools across the country.
The 2024 GCSE results illustrate this consistency. Over 38% of all grades were awarded at 9-7 (equivalent to the old A*-A), significantly above the national average. Furthermore, more than 20% of grades were at the elite 9-8 level.
These outcomes are achieved without an aggressive selection policy. The school describes itself as "broadly non-selective" in the younger years, tightening up slightly for Senior entry, yet it consistently adds value to pupils of all abilities. The Science department is particularly formidable, with triple science uptake high and results to match.
England ranks and key metrics (where available)
GCSE 9–7
38.44%
% of students achieving grades 9-7
The curriculum is structured to ensure smooth transitions. In the Lower School (Reception to Year 5), the focus is on building core skills in literacy and numeracy, but specialist teaching is introduced early. Children as young as four receive specialist instruction in French, PE, and Music, normalising the idea of moving between teachers.
By Year 6, pupils move into a transition phase where they are taught almost exclusively by subject specialists, preparing them for the Senior School. This "Middle School" feel prevents the shock that often accompanies the move to secondary education.
In the Senior School (Years 7-11), class sizes are kept small, typically around 15-18. This allows for a teaching style that is interactive and responsive. Teachers know exactly who hasn't done their homework, but more importantly, they know who needs a confidence boost or an extra challenge. The curriculum remains broad, with Art, Drama, and Music given equal status alongside STEM subjects.
Without a Sixth Form, the destination of leavers is a key measure of success. St Nicholas students are highly sought after by local sixth form providers.
A significant proportion progress to prestigious independent schools such as Bishop's Stortford College, The Leys, Haileybury, and Felsted, often securing academic or sports scholarships. Others move on to high-performing state grammar schools and sixth form colleges, including Hockerill Anglo-European College and The Hertfordshire & Essex High School.
The school views the 16+ transition as a vital life skill. Students are guided through the application process with mock interviews and careers advice, ensuring they choose the right environment for their next step.
Entry points are flexible, but the main intakes are at Nursery, Reception, and Year 7.
For Reception, the process is gentle. Children are invited for a "taster" session to see if they settle. There is no formal exam, but the school looks for a level of readiness to learn.
For Year 7 entry, the process is more formal. Candidates sit an entrance examination in January of Year 6, covering English, Mathematics, and Verbal Reasoning. Crucially, this is accompanied by an interview with the Headmaster. The school is looking for potential and "fit" as much as raw data. A reference from the child's current school is also required.
Deadlines matter here. For Year 7 entry in September 2026, the application deadline is 1 December 2025. Families are advised to register well in advance, as places are competitive.
Pastoral care was a headline strength in the 2025 ISI inspection, which found the school met all standards and praised the strong relationships between staff and pupils. The report noted that pupils feel "valued as individuals" and "listened to."
The pastoral structure is built around Form Tutors, who see their group twice a day. They are supported by Heads of House and a dedicated pastoral team. The school's "River of Life" PSHE curriculum is distinctive, tackling modern issues like digital resilience and mental health with refreshing directness.
The extracurricular offer is extensive and uses the 14-acre site to full effect.
Facilities include a heated outdoor swimming pool, tennis courts, and large playing fields. The school punches above its weight in local leagues, particularly in football, netball, and cricket. The swimming squad is notably strong.
The performing arts are central to school life. The purpose-built theatre hosts major productions—recent shows have included Matilda and The Lion King. Music is pervasive, with peripatetic teachers offering lessons in everything from cello to electric guitar.
The "activities" slot is built into the timetable. Options range from the cerebral (Chess, Coding, Debating) to the active (Karate, Forest School). The Duke of Edinburgh's Award is popular in Year 10, with high completion rates for the Bronze award.
Fees are inclusive of VAT, lunch, textbooks, and most curriculum trips.
Scholarships are available for entry into Year 7. These are awarded for excellence in Academia, Art, Music, and Sport. They typically offer a reduction in fees and carry the expectation that the scholar will contribute significantly to that area of school life.
Means-tested bursaries are available for families who would otherwise be unable to afford the fees. These are rigorous and reviewed annually, focusing on widening access to the school.
Fees data coming soon.
The school is located in Old Harlow, just off the M11. While many parents drive, the school operates an extensive minibus network. Routes cover Epping, North Weald, Bishop's Stortford, Sawbridgeworth, and Ongar.
Wraparound care is robust, catering to working parents. Breakfast Club starts at 7:30am, and After School Care runs until 6:00pm. Holiday clubs operate during the major breaks, providing year-round support.
No Sixth Form. The school ends at 16. Families must be prepared for a school move after GCSEs. While the school supports this well, it is an extra transition point that all-through 18+ schools avoid.
Transportation. The location is semi-rural. It is not within easy walking distance of a train station. Families who do not drive or use the school bus may find access difficult.
Fee Increases. The published fees are inclusive of VAT, reflecting the recent government changes. Families should ensure they are looking at the gross figure when budgeting.
St Nicholas School is a hidden gem in the Essex independent sector. It offers the facilities and academic standards of a much larger school but retains the warmth and intimacy of a village primary. It is best suited to families who want their children to be confident and capable without being arrogant. The results speak for themselves, but it is the happy, grounded nature of the pupils that leaves the lasting impression.
Yes. The 2025 Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI) report confirmed that the school meets all standards. Inspectors praised the quality of education and the excellent personal development of pupils. Academically, it is the highest-performing school in Harlow for GCSE results.
For the 2025/2026 academic year, fees range from £4,821 per term for Reception to £6,719 per term for Years 9-11. These fees are inclusive of VAT and lunch.
No. The school educates children up to age 16 (Year 11). Leavers progress to a wide range of local sixth form colleges, grammar schools, and independent schools.
Entry to the Senior School (Year 7) is selective, involving an entrance exam and interview. However, the school looks for potential and character, not just raw academic data. Early registration is recommended as the school is popular and places are limited.
For Year 7 entry in September 2026, the application deadline is 1 December 2025. For other year groups, applications are considered on a rolling basis subject to availability.
Get in touch with the school directly
Disclaimer
Information on this page is compiled, analysed, and processed from publicly available sources including the Department for Education (DfE), Ofsted, the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI), the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests, and official school websites.
Our rankings, metrics, and assessments are derived from this data using our own methodologies and represent our independent analysis rather than official standings.
While we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee that all information is current, complete, or error-free. Data may change without notice, and schools and/or local authorities should be contacted directly to verify any details before making decisions.
FindMySchool does not endorse any particular school, and rankings reflect specific metrics rather than overall quality.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information provided. If you believe any information is inaccurate, please contact us.
