In spring 1941, when German parachute mines damaged the original St Andrew's Convent School beyond recognition, the nuns evacuated and offered their building to the government for civil defence training. Eighty-three years later, the school that rose from those wartime ruins stands as one of Surrey's strongest comprehensive schools, achieving Outstanding across every category in its May 2024 Ofsted inspection. Nearly 1,600 students aged 11-18 now inhabit a campus that blends Victorian heritage with contemporary facilities, including a state-of-the-art sixth form and performance arts building completed in 2008. What sets this school apart is neither its architectural elegance nor its academic firepower alone, but rather the integration of Catholic values into every aspect of daily life. Students speak of belonging to something larger than themselves. Results tell a consistent story of excellence: 79% achieved grade 5 or above in both English and maths at GCSE in 2024, well above the England average of 46%. The school ranks 400th in England for GCSE outcomes (FindMySchool ranking), placing it comfortably in the national high tier (top 9%). At A-level, 85% of students achieved A*-B grades, with the school ranking 179th in England for sixth form results (FindMySchool ranking). Beyond the numbers, St Andrew's is categorised as a Specialist Maths and Computing College, designating it among Surrey's ten most popular state schools. This is unquestionably a school where academic ambition meets pastoral care, where faith is lived rather than taught.
The campus itself speaks to the school's development across generations. The central red-brick Victorian buildings housing Years 7-11 date to the 1900s, while the Earl Building, opened in 2017 and named after John Earl who served as Chair of Governors, provides dedicated spaces for History, Geography and Languages. The sixth form and performance arts building, completed in 2008, created a physical separation that allows older students independence whilst maintaining connection to the main school community. This architectural diversity signals that St Andrew's has not been static; it has continually evolved to meet its pupils' needs.
The FMS Inspection Score is FindMySchool's proprietary analysis based on official Ofsted and ISI inspection reports. It converts ratings into a standardised 1–10 scale for fair comparison across all schools in England.
Disclaimer: The FMS Inspection Score is an independent analysis by FindMySchool. It is not endorsed by or affiliated with Ofsted or ISI. Always refer to the official Ofsted or ISI report for the full picture of a school’s inspection outcome.
The school has a clear sense of identity shaped by its setting and community. Inspectors found that pupils feel "extremely proud of their school" and that "values of kindness and respect are evident in the exceptionally positive relationships pupils have with each other and with staff." The school's culture of high standards is matched equally by genuine care. Year 10 student testimonies describe a place where adults know them individually, where concerns are taken seriously, and where pupils feel "empowered to speak up" because they trust their safety is prioritised. One pupil captured learning here as "like building bricks," a metaphor the inspection report echoed, suggesting incremental mastery rather than rote memorisation.
Sixth form students embody leadership explicitly centred on service. They manage charity work, lead pupil voice initiatives, and mentor younger students in ways that underscore the Catholic mission beyond religious education. A 15:1 student-teacher ratio, whilst higher than some schools, means adults know their cohorts well. Headteacher Alan Mitchell and his leadership team have cultivated what Ofsted described as a culture where "staff are relentless in their efforts to help pupils and families," operating on a "we do not give up on them" principle. Staff speak of feeling respected and valued; loyalty to the school is notably high, and professional development is prioritised not as an add-on but as central to maintaining excellence.
In the 2023-24 academic year, 79% of St Andrew's pupils achieved grade 5 or above in both English and maths, compared to the England average of 46%. This represents solid outperformance of the national benchmark. The average Attainment 8 score was 64.3, above the England average of 45.9. More importantly, the Progress 8 score of +1.2 indicates that students here made significantly above-average progress from their primary school starting points. Progress 8 measures value-added: it tells us that pupils at St Andrew's advanced faster than statistically similar pupils in England, a metric of genuine quality teaching.
The school's GCSE rank of 400 places it in the national high performance band (top 9% in England). Locally, it ranks 2nd among Leatherhead secondary schools, rivalling selective alternatives despite operating a fully comprehensive, non-selective intake. The English Baccalaureate represents a particular strength: 35% of pupils achieved the full EBacc (English, mathematics, science, language, and humanities), well above national rates. This breadth of ambition in subjects means pupils develop genuine intellectual range rather than narrow specialism.
The sixth form operates at consistently high levels. In 2024, 85% of A-level entries achieved A*-B grades. The A* percentage reached 17% and A-grades comprised 37%, giving an impressive combined A*-A showing of 54%. The school ranks 179th in England for A-level outcomes (FindMySchool ranking), placing it in the national high tier (top 7% ). For context, this performance exceeds the vast majority of schools and rivals many independent schools. The spread of A-level subjects offered (reports indicate 25+ A-level options) allows specialisation without enforced rigidity.
University destinations reflect this A-level strength. 72% of the 2024 leavers cohort progressed to university, with one student securing an Oxbridge place (from 15 applications). This figure, whilst modest in Oxbridge terms, is entirely respectable for a comprehensive school. Beyond those headline destinations, alumni move into Russell Group universities and specialist institutions across the UK. The careers programme is described by Ofsted as "excellent," deliberately exposing pupils to "a variety of representatives from the world of work, education and training."
England ranks and key metrics (where available)
A-Level A*-B
84.77%
% of students achieving grades A*-B
GCSE 9–7
51.6%
% of students achieving grades 9-7
Inspectors found that "the curriculum prepares pupils extremely well for examinations but also inspires them to see their learning in a wider context." This balance, rigour with breadth, pervades every key stage. The curriculum design is ambitious: pupils study a broad range of subjects from Year 7 onwards and encounter "high levels of challenge from the start." Subject specialists receive clear guidance on adapting teaching for pupils with additional needs, and differentiation is deliberate rather than arbitrary.
Reading is woven through the entire school. Pupils read routinely and widely, including across subjects. Where pupils have specific reading gaps, targeted intervention addresses these directly. In sixth form, students benefit from a "strong emphasis on deepening their learning and thinking, for example through academic reading." This scaffolded approach, from building foundational skills to sophisticated textual analysis, develops intellectual confidence.
The teaching methods lean into resilience building. Inspectors noted that "tasks become increasingly demanding over time. Pupils approach them enthusiastically because of the resilience and skills they develop." Staff routinely check understanding and provide feedback that students actively use to improve work. The result is that pupils become "confident and independent learners, regardless of starting points." This is pedagogically sound: confidence precedes achievement.
Quality of Education
Outstanding
Behaviour & Attitudes
Outstanding
Personal Development
Outstanding
Leadership & Management
Outstanding
FMS Inspection Score calculated by FindMySchool based on official inspection data.
Beyond the university pipeline, the school consciously prepares pupils for "citizenship in modern Britain." The personal development curriculum is "carefully and ambitiously sequenced from Year 7 to 13," with themes revisited at age-appropriate levels. Pupils explore contemporary social issues sensitively and learn to navigate complex modern realities both online and offline. This is not citizenship education reduced to a checklist; it is holistic character development.
For those not pursuing university, the school emphasises apprenticeships and technical pathways equally. The careers programme ensures that students understand the full spectrum of post-16 options. With 72% proceeding to university and proportions entering further education and apprenticeships documented in the leavers data, the school demonstrates successful progression across multiple routes rather than a single university-focused funnel.
Total Offers
1
Offer Success Rate: 6.7%
Cambridge
1
Offers
Oxford
0
Offers
Extracurricular life at St Andrew's is extensive and carefully structured to ensure access for all. Inspectors explicitly noted that pupils "participate enthusiastically in the wide range of activities on offer such as clubs, trips and formal schemes such as the Duke of Edinburgh Award." The school ensures that financial barrier, background, or perceived ability never prevents participation.
Sport operates at multiple levels. The school's vibrant PE department manages competitive fixtures across football, basketball, rugby, cricket, tennis, badminton, and other sports, with sixth-form students visible on the Instagram feed competing at senior levels. The sports programme balances representation teams competing at county and regional level with recreational provision ensuring every student can participate. Facilities include standard playing fields and courts necessary for a comprehensive programme, with water-based activities accessible through off-site arrangements.
The 2008-completed sixth form and performance arts building represents dedicated investment in creative arts. Music forms a significant pillar. The school fields a chapel choir, symphony orchestra, and smaller ensembles including jazz groups. One student won the Barbara Lee Cup for Operatic Aria at the Redhill & Reigate Music Festival in May 2013, suggesting sustained engagement with performance music. Drama is similarly active, with school productions utilising the purpose-built performance spaces. These are not peripheral activities; they are central to school life and explicitly developed as character-building pursuits.
Given the school's Specialist Maths and Computing College designation, STEM clubs and competitions feature prominently. The school's commitment to mathematics extends beyond the classroom into enrichment programmes, coding clubs, and cross-curricular applications. Students participate in maths competitions and coding challenges. Physics and chemistry benefit from well-resourced laboratories and specialist teaching, with pupils able to pursue practical investigations that reinforce theoretical learning.
Charity work and community service feature prominently in the pastoral calendar. Sixth-form leaders coordinate charity initiatives, suggesting that pupils develop genuine understanding of social responsibility rather than tokenistic service. Retreats are offered at Key Stage 4 and 5, providing residential experiences where pupils "focus on issues that help them to develop." These are not obligatory religious exercises for non-Catholic students but rather opportunities for reflection and growth offered inclusively.
The Duke of Edinburgh Award Scheme operates at Bronze, Silver and Gold levels, with evidence of sustained participation. Leadership opportunities abound: sixth-form students mentor younger year groups, lead assemblies, and participate in student councils. The inspection report highlighted that "sixth-form students are impressive embodiments of [school values] for younger pupils."
St Andrew's operates on a fully non-selective basis. The school's admissions criteria prioritise children of practising Catholic families (as a voluntary aided Catholic school), but applications are welcome from families of all faiths and none. The school is consistently oversubscribed, with demand substantially outstripping places. In the most recent admissions data, the school received approximately three applications for every place offered at Year 7, reflecting its standing as one of Surrey's most sought-after comprehensives.
For sixth form entry, students must typically achieve a minimum of 5 GCSE passes including English and mathematics, with higher grades often required for selective A-level subjects like sciences. The sixth form opens to external candidates, welcoming students from other schools. The current sixth form cohort numbers approximately 370 students from a total roll of 1,570, a healthy two-form intake across Years 12 and 13.
Applications
691
Total received
Places Offered
234
Subscription Rate
3.0x
Applications per place
The school's approach to pastoral care is explicitly underpinned by its Catholic ethos but experienced as inclusive by all pupils. Every student begins the day in prayer within their form tutor group. Weekly year assemblies, led by students and staff, explore a weekly "Theme" that underpins tutor time discussions. Form tutors and pupils use a dedicated Prayer Booklet with mini-assemblies personally written for St Andrew's. This is not imposed chapel-style religiosity; it is a rhythmic spiritual practice embedded in ordinary school life.
Ofsted found safeguarding arrangements to be effective. The school has built what the report describes as "an open and positive culture around safeguarding that puts pupils' interests first." Pupils feel safe; parents expressed confidence in the school's responsiveness to concerns. The chaplaincy supports pastoral work, and specialist counselling is available through regular visits from trained practitioners. For pupils with special educational needs or disabilities, staff adapt teaching and provide individualised support with a "we do not give up on them" ethos. This is not a school that expects students to conform or disappear; it actively supports those who struggle to meet expectations.
Behaviour expectations are clear and consistently maintained. Attendance is excellent at 97%. This does not emerge from fear; inspectors found "exceptional positive relationships" and "excellent behaviour in lessons and social time." The culture of respect for self and others "demands high standards" and systems ensure consistency. Where pupils do struggle, individualised support is provided. There is a genuine distinction between discipline-as-punishment and discipline-as-structure; St Andrew's exemplifies the latter.
The standard school day runs 8:50am to 3:20pm for Years 7-11. Sixth form schedules vary depending on timetabled modules but typically follow the main school pattern with free periods in Years 12-13.
The school is located on Grange Road, approximately a 10-minute walk from Leatherhead train station. Bus services including the number 479 provide regular connections. The Leatherhead Bus Station is 0.4 miles away. Parking for parents visiting the school is available but limited; the school's location within the town makes bus and train access preferable.
The school operates a catering facility providing hot lunches and snacks. Sixth-form students have the option to leave site at lunchtime.
Given the Specialist Computing College designation, IT facilities are well-resourced. Students have access to computer laboratories and modern networked systems. Digital literacy is embedded across subjects, not confined to computing lessons.
High Demand for Entry: This is one of Surrey's most oversubscribed schools. Families living outside the immediate catchment area should not assume a place is guaranteed. The school's non-selective admissions policy and strong reputation mean that proximity and faith criteria are the deciding factors when oversubscribed. Check current admissions procedures and distance thresholds directly with the school.
Strong Results Culture: St Andrew's maintains a results-focused environment. Whilst pastoral care is strong, the school operates with structured discipline and clear academic expectations. Students who struggle with formal schooling structures or who resist authoritative environments may find the culture restrictive. The school describes itself as offering "discipline, structure and common purpose" as "solid foundations"; families should understand this commitment is genuine and central to the school's identity.
Faith Character is Genuine: For families drawn to the Catholic ethos, this is a considerable strength. For families uncomfortable with daily prayer, regular Masses, and religious teaching woven through school life, this is an important consideration. Whilst the school welcomes and respects families of all faiths, Catholic practices are integrated into daily rhythms, not peripheral additions. The Diocese of Arundel and Brighton provides oversight, and a Section 48 SIAMS inspection is scheduled before July 2025.
Sixth Form External Recruitment: Whilst the sixth form opens to external candidates, places are competitive. Students from other schools seeking entry must meet published GCSE thresholds and should understand they are joining an established community with its own culture.
St Andrew's Catholic School is among England's stronger comprehensive schools. It consistently delivers academic excellence, with GCSE and A-level results that rival many independent schools whilst maintaining a fully inclusive, non-selective intake. The May 2024 Ofsted inspection awarding Outstanding across all categories was not a surprise to those familiar with the school's track record; it validated years of intentional work by leadership and staff to combine ambitious learning with genuine pastoral care. Teaching is strong, sixth form provision is sophisticated, and the school's Catholic ethos is woven authentically through daily life without alienating families of other faiths or none.
This is not a school without challenge. Entry is competitive. The results-focused culture demands engagement from families. And the Catholic character is explicit and lived, not nominal. But for families within reach of a place, seeking a comprehensive school with genuine academic rigour, strong pastoral support, and a values-led community, St Andrew's offers exactly what it promises: a school where students become "the best they can be" academically, spiritually and morally. The real question is not whether St Andrew's is a good school, the evidence is overwhelming, but whether its specific culture is the right fit for your child.
Yes. St Andrew's was rated Outstanding by Ofsted in May 2024 across all categories: Quality of Education, Behaviour and Attitudes, Personal Development, Leadership and Management, and Sixth Form Provision. GCSE results show 79% achieving grade 5 or above in English and maths (England average 46%). A-level results show 85% achieving A*-B grades. The school ranks 400th in England for GCSE outcomes and 179th for A-level results (FindMySchool rankings), placing it in the national high tier. This combination of inspection excellence, strong results, and inclusive admissions makes it one of Surrey's strongest comprehensive schools.
St Andrew's is a Roman Catholic voluntary aided school, part of the Diocese of Arundel and Brighton. Catholic practice is genuinely integrated into daily life: students begin each day with prayer in their form tutor groups, participate in weekly year assemblies exploring spiritual themes, and are invited to participate in school Masses and retreats. This is not superficial; inspectors found the school operates with a strong Catholic ethos. Families of other faiths or none are welcome and respected, but they should understand that Catholic practice is central to school life, not optional.
Very. The school receives approximately three applications for every place available at Year 7. The oversubscribed status means that admissions criteria (including faith background and proximity to the school) are strictly applied when places are allocated. Families interested in applying should check current admissions policies with the school directly and verify their distance from the school gates, as distance thresholds vary year to year based on demand.
The sixth form serves approximately 370 students across Years 12-13 and benefits from dedicated facilities including the 2008-built sixth form and performance arts building. A-level results are strong: 85% achieved A*-B in 2024. The sixth form operates with greater independence than the main school, with free periods built into timetables. External candidates can apply, though places are competitive and students must meet published GCSE thresholds. Sixth form students play leadership roles, mentoring younger pupils and managing service initiatives, creating a mature learning environment.
Extracurricular life is extensive. Sports include football, rugby, cricket, tennis, basketball, and other fixtures managed by an active PE department. Music includes chapel choir, symphony orchestra, smaller ensembles and drama productions using purpose-built performance spaces. Duke of Edinburgh Award operates at multiple levels. Clubs span academic subjects, community service, and pastimes. The school explicitly ensures all pupils can participate regardless of background or perceived ability. Trips and residential experiences, including retreats at Key Stage 4 and 5, are regular features of the calendar.
The school describes itself as "ambitious and inclusive." Staff adapt teaching to support pupils with additional needs, and individualised support is provided where pupils struggle to meet standard expectations. The school's philosophy is "we do not give up on them." Formal SEND assessment and support operate within the mainstream framework. For pupils with more complex needs requiring specialist provision, families should contact the school to discuss whether mainstream with support is appropriate, or whether specialist schools might be better suited.
Get in touch with the school directly
Disclaimer
Information on this page is compiled, analysed, and processed from publicly available sources including the Department for Education (DfE), Ofsted, the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI), the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests, and official school websites.
Our rankings, metrics, and assessments are derived from this data using our own methodologies and represent our independent analysis rather than official standings.
While we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee that all information is current, complete, or error-free. Data may change without notice, and schools and/or local authorities should be contacted directly to verify any details before making decisions.
FindMySchool does not endorse any particular school, and rankings reflect specific metrics rather than overall quality.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information provided. If you believe any information is inaccurate, please contact us.
