The FMS Inspection Score is FindMySchool's proprietary analysis based on official Ofsted and ISI inspection reports. It converts ratings into a standardised 1–10 scale for fair comparison across all schools in England.
Disclaimer: The FMS Inspection Score is an independent analysis by FindMySchool. It is not endorsed by or affiliated with Ofsted or ISI. Always refer to the official Ofsted or ISI report for the full picture of a school’s inspection outcome.
Oldhill Community School, a state-funded primary serving children aged 3 to 11 in Stoke Newington, closed on 31 August 2025 following a merger with Harrington Hill Primary School. The school operated on Oldhill Street, N16 6LR, within the London Borough of Hackney, holding a Good Ofsted rating from its most recent inspection in March 2023. Designed with capacity for 420 pupils, the school ultimately served a much smaller roll, operating at approximately one form of entry instead of its potential two, leading to an unsustainable financial position.
The school was part of a broader reorganisation of Hackney primary schools prompted by falling rolls across the borough, where pupil numbers decreased by 2,399 over seven years. Oldhill's pupils, including those in its specialist Autistic Spectrum Condition (ASC) provision for 10 children, transferred to the enlarged Harrington Hill Primary School.
Oldhill Community School was rooted in its multicultural and multilingual community in Stoke Newington, taking pride in diversity and valuing each child as an individual. The school's ethos centred on respecting differences and creating an inclusive environment where children from varied backgrounds could learn together. Oldhill also operated a children's centre offering childcare and early years provision for children from six months to five years, supporting working families in the area.
Leadership during the final years of operation was under headteacher Jacquline Benjamin, who oversaw a school that maintained a Good Ofsted rating through its 2023 inspection. The school's setting, within a building capable of accommodating two forms of entry, stood in the heart of the Cazenove ward, part of the Hackney North and Stoke Newington parliamentary constituency. The school maintained a specialist provision for children with Autistic Spectrum Condition, an Additional Resource Provision (ARP) that supported 10 pupils and moved with them to Harrington Hill following the merger.
The decision to close Oldhill was driven by systemic financial pressures. Operating at half its intended capacity, the school faced a projected accumulated deficit of £1.7 million by April 2025. Hackney Council concluded that the financial position was unrecoverable and the school unsustainable in the medium term. Despite community opposition—parents describing the decision as "short-sighted" and "financially driven"—the closure proceeded as part of a wider reorganisation affecting six Hackney primary schools.
Oldhill Community School's most recent published attainment data showed performance in line with national averages. In the latest Key Stage 2 results, 80% of pupils reached the expected standard in reading, writing and maths combined, well above the national average of 62%. The school achieved an average scaled score of 107 in reading and 105 in both maths and grammar, punctuation and spelling, indicating solid foundational skills.
Nearly 29% of pupils achieved the higher standard in reading, writing and maths combined, significantly above the national average of 8%. Science attainment was particularly strong, with 92% of pupils reaching the expected standard compared to 82% nationally. In reading, 39% achieved high scores, and 25% reached greater depth in writing. These results placed Oldhill at the 38th percentile nationally, ranking 5,747 out of England's primary schools and 35th locally within Hackney.
The school's performance reflected consistency rather than exceptional attainment. Pupils made steady progress in core subjects, with average scaled scores remaining close to the national standard of 100. The school's ability to support pupils with additional needs, particularly through its ASC provision, was a recognised strength, with tailored support enabling children with autism to access mainstream learning alongside specialist input.
England ranks and key metrics (where available)
Reading, Writing & Maths
79.67%
% of pupils achieving expected standard
Oldhill Community School occupied a site designed for two forms of entry, offering substantial space and facilities for primary education. The main building included general teaching areas, specialist rooms, and spaces for early years provision through the co-located children's centre. The site's scale allowed for varied learning environments, though underutilisation meant some capacity remained unfilled in the school's final years.
The children's centre extended provision beyond the school day, offering childcare from six months to five years and out-of-school care for older children. This integrated approach supported families seeking full-day care and early childhood education in one setting. The school also ran a nursery for three- and four-year-olds, providing a seamless transition into Reception.
Extracurricular details and specific awards were not widely documented in the school's final years, though the focus remained on creating a supportive, inclusive environment for children from diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds. The school's atmosphere reflected the close-knit community of Stoke Newington, with pupils drawn primarily from the surrounding residential streets.
Admissions to Oldhill Community School were managed by Hackney Council under the standard local authority primary admissions process. In its final intake year, the school received 19 applications for 19 places, reflecting an undersubscribed status with a ratio of applications to places of just 32%. No first-preference applicants were turned away, indicating accessible entry with minimal competition—a sharp contrast to many other Hackney primaries that regularly oversubscribe.
The school's undersubscription was central to the closure decision. Operating at one form of entry rather than two, the school could not fill sufficient places to sustain its financial viability. Hackney Council noted that the site was capable of accommodating 60 pupils per year group but was serving only around 30. This persistent shortfall in pupil numbers led to a projected deficit of £1.7 million by April 2025, written off by the council upon closure.
The catchment area encompassed parts of Stoke Newington, within easy walking distance of Harrington Hill Primary School (less than 1,000 metres or approximately 15 minutes on foot). Pupils affected by the closure transferred to Harrington Hill, which expanded from one to two forms of entry to accommodate them. The ASC provision moved intact, ensuring continuity for children with specialist needs.
Parents and families expressed frustration with the closure process, arguing that the decision prioritised financial considerations over educational continuity and the emotional impact on children, particularly those with SEND. Community reaction highlighted concerns about the loss of a familiar school environment and the disruption to established relationships between pupils, staff and families.
Applications
19
Total received
Places Offered
19
Oldhill Community School closed not because of academic failure—it held a Good Ofsted rating and delivered results in line with national standards—but because of systemic financial unsustainability driven by falling rolls across Hackney. The school's strengths lay in its inclusive ethos, strong support for children with additional needs, and solid academic performance. Its multicultural community and specialist ASC provision were valued assets, and the children's centre offered integrated early years care.
However, operating at half capacity within a building designed for twice as many pupils created an unrecoverable financial position. The decision to merge with Harrington Hill, while contentious, aimed to preserve educational provision in a financially viable structure. For parents whose children attended Oldhill, the closure marked the end of a community institution; for the wider system, it reflected difficult choices necessitated by demographic shifts.
Oldhill's legacy lies in its commitment to diversity, inclusion and specialist support. The transfer of its ASC provision and pupils to Harrington Hill aimed to maintain continuity, though the emotional and practical disruption of school closure cannot be understated. For families in Stoke Newington, the merger reshaped local primary provision, consolidating resources into fewer, larger schools.
No. Oldhill Community School closed on 31 August 2025. Pupils merged with Harrington Hill Primary School, which expanded to accommodate them.
The school closed due to low pupil numbers and an unrecoverable financial deficit projected to reach £1.7 million by April 2025. Operating at one form of entry instead of two, the school could not sustain itself financially.
Pupils transferred to Harrington Hill Primary School, less than 1,000 metres away. The school's Autistic Spectrum Condition provision moved with them, ensuring continuity for children with specialist needs. Staffing arrangements were managed as part of the merger process.
The school was rated Good in its most recent inspection in March 2023.
Harrington Hill Primary School is located within a 15-minute walk of the former Oldhill site. Contact Hackney Council for admissions and enrolment details .
Details of future use for the Oldhill Street site were not specified at the time of closure. Contact Hackney Council for updates on the building's future.
Get in touch with the school directly
Disclaimer
Information on this page is compiled, analysed, and processed from publicly available sources including the Department for Education (DfE), Ofsted, the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI), the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests, and official school websites.
Our rankings, metrics, and assessments are derived from this data using our own methodologies and represent our independent analysis rather than official standings.
While we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee that all information is current, complete, or error-free. Data may change without notice, and schools and/or local authorities should be contacted directly to verify any details before making decisions.
FindMySchool does not endorse any particular school, and rankings reflect specific metrics rather than overall quality.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information provided. If you believe any information is inaccurate, please contact us.
