An 11 to 18 school with deep roots in Ryedale, Malton School combines a large, comprehensive intake with an unusually structured personal development offer. Lessons run in 75 minute blocks and Thursdays finish later than the rest of the week, creating space for planned enrichment rather than treating it as an optional add-on.
History matters here, but it is not museum-piece history. The modern school came into being in September 1971, and the motto, unitate fortiores (stronger through becoming one), is tied directly to that merger of earlier schools.
The latest Ofsted inspection (December 2023) judged the school Good overall, with the sixth form judged Outstanding.
The school’s identity is shaped by two influences that sit comfortably together: a long institutional story, and a practical focus on preparing students for adult life. The historical thread goes back to 1547, founded by Robert Holgate, Archbishop of York, with later expansion on Middlecave Road in 1911 and substantial development through the post-war decades.
That sense of continuity is most visible through the house system, which is tightly linked to local history rather than being a decorative overlay. Students join one of five houses, Carlisle, Fitzwilliam, Holgate, Tudor, and Willoughby, and points accumulate through praise points into a year-end House Shield. There is also a clear student-facing “progression ladder” in the form of house ties and colours that rewards sustained effort and attendance, not only one-off achievements.
A distinct feature of school culture is how deliberately it has built routine around reading and personal development. Formal observations describe an ambitious curriculum supported by technology, and a structured push on reading, including identification of reading ability and targeted support for students who need help. This matters for families because it signals the school is aiming for consistency across a broad intake, not only stretching the most academic students.
Leadership stability also shapes day-to-day tone. Rob Williams has been headteacher since September 2006. A long tenure can be a major advantage in a secondary setting, because it usually correlates with settled expectations, established routines, and sustained investment choices rather than constant reinvention.
At GCSE, the headline indicators suggest outcomes close to the England picture overall, with some areas that merit attention depending on your child’s profile.
Attainment 8 is 46.6.
Progress 8 is -0.09, which indicates students make slightly less progress than others nationally with similar starting points.
The average EBacc APS is 4.17.
11.4% of pupils achieved grades 5 or above across the EBacc suite.
The combination implies that, while many students do well, the school’s overall results are not driven by a high-EBacc, strongly academic entry profile. For families, the implication is practical: students who are strongly academic, especially those who want a very traditional EBacc-heavy route, may need to use option choices, subject support, and independent study habits to fully maximise outcomes here. The academic support structures and curriculum breadth described in formal observations are helpful foundations, but the onus still sits with the student to take advantage of them.
A key point of reassurance is that subject access is broad. Formal observations confirm a wide range of subjects and well planned lessons, with strong subject knowledge from staff. That breadth gives students room to find the right fit at Key Stage 4.
The sixth form is a significant part of the school offer, and the published figures suggest a mixed picture: strong inspection outcomes, but average-to-below-average attainment patterns in the grades profile.
Ranked 1,599th in England and 1st in Malton for A-level outcomes (FindMySchool ranking based on official data).
3.98% of grades at A*.
14.16% of grades at A.
23.01% of grades at B.
41.15% of grades at A* to B.
England averages are 23.6% at A* to A and 47.2% at A* to B.
In plain terms, sixth form grades sit below the England averages placing the school beyond the middle 35% and into the lower band nationally. Yet, the local position, 1st in Malton, suggests it remains a key post-16 option in its immediate area.
This is a good example of why families should triangulate data rather than over-weight a single measure. A-level outcomes, inspection findings, subject fit, and student maturity all matter. Families comparing post-16 options can use the FindMySchool Local Hub page and Comparison Tool to review A-level outcomes side-by-side with other nearby providers, then sanity-check that against subject availability and enrichment.
England ranks and key metrics (where available)
A-Level A*-B
41.15%
% of students achieving grades A*-B
The core academic proposition is a broad curriculum, delivered with clear structure, backed by a long-running approach to learning technology.
One concrete example is the “personal tablets” model referenced in formal observations, where students access learning materials via tablets, and some materials are automatically translated for students with English as an additional language. The evidence point is important because it implies the technology is designed to remove access barriers rather than being novelty use. The practical implication for families is that students who benefit from scaffolding, clear access to resources, and revision workflows can thrive, provided they are supported to use the tools effectively rather than passively.
A second example is the school’s emphasis on reading. Formal observations describe a planned approach that identifies literacy levels, including in sixth form, and provides timely support for students who struggle. In a secondary setting, literacy is a multiplier: it supports progress across humanities, sciences, and vocational pathways, and can be decisive at GCSE when exam questions become more language-dense.
The main development area is also clearly signposted. Formal observations identify inconsistency in connecting prior learning to new learning in some lessons, which can limit students’ ability to build deep understanding across linked topics. For parents, the practical takeaway is that students who are not naturally “joiners of dots” may need extra support with revision strategies and cumulative learning, especially in GCSE and A-level subjects that build heavily year on year.
Quality of Education
Good
Behaviour & Attitudes
Good
Personal Development
Good
Leadership & Management
Good
Published destinations data in the provided dataset is limited for this school, so the most reliable signals come from two places: the sixth form curriculum breadth and the school’s careers structure.
Oxbridge outcomes in the measured period show 12 applications and 1 student securing a place (via Cambridge rather than Oxford). That is not a defining pipeline in the way it is for highly selective schools, but it does show that the route is viable for an exceptional applicant with the right grades, support, and subject match.
What is more consistently emphasised is preparedness for multiple routes. Formal observations state that pupils are well supported with careers advice and guidance, and that the school meets the requirements of provider access legislation around technical education and apprenticeships. The school’s careers programme explicitly references work experience as part of its Key Stage 5 personalised curriculum, alongside activities such as careers fairs, speakers, and Unifrog.
For families, the implication is that post-16 is designed to keep options open: university, apprenticeships, and vocational pathways. The evidence suggests a school that wants students to make informed choices, rather than defaulting into a narrow set of outcomes.
Total Offers
1
Offer Success Rate: 8.3%
Cambridge
1
Offers
Oxford
0
Offers
Year 7 applications are coordinated through North Yorkshire Council rather than directly through the school. The school’s published admission number is 150 places each year.
For September 2026 entry, North Yorkshire’s published secondary timeline is clear:
Applications open 12 September 2025
Deadline to apply 31 October 2025
Last date for changes 30 November 2025
National Offer Day 2 March 2026
Appeal deadline 13 April 2026
Open events appear to follow a stable annual pattern. For example, the school ran an open evening on 25 September 2025 for prospective Year 5 and Year 6 families. For 2026 and beyond, it is sensible to treat late September as the typical timing, then confirm the exact date each year on the school’s calendar.
If the school is oversubscribed, families should be prepared for the possibility of appeal. The school confirms that it has been oversubscribed in recent years and points families towards the independent appeals route.
Year 12 applications are made direct to the sixth form rather than via the local authority. Applications open in November of Year 11, following the sixth form open evening.
For September 2026 entry, the sixth form application deadline is Friday, 30 January 2026.
Entry requirements are clearly set out:
Minimum of 4 GCSEs at grade 4 or above including English or Maths for vocational courses
A general minimum of 5 GCSEs at grade 4 or above including English and Maths for A-level courses
Some subjects have higher requirements
The school also runs structured transition and taster activity. The published calendar includes sixth form taster days on 07 January 2026 and 08 January 2026 for Year 11 students.
Applications
293
Total received
Places Offered
160
Subscription Rate
1.8x
Apps per place
Pastoral structures are unusually explicit and multi-layered for a mainstream secondary, which is a positive signal for families who want clarity about where responsibility sits.
Each year group has a Head of Year for day-to-day issues, with Key Stage Directors supporting that work, and the pastoral team is led by an Assistant Headteacher responsible for pastoral care and safeguarding who is also the Designated Safeguarding Lead. Referrals routes are clear: Heads of Year work with tutors and can refer students to a School Mentor, the Wellbeing in Mind Team, and other targeted support.
The Wellbeing in Mind Team is described as an NHS team based in school supporting common emotional wellbeing difficulties such as low mood, anxiety, and low self-esteem, with the ability to connect to external services for higher-need cases. In addition, the school employs an independent therapist (named on the school site) for more individual support, typically for up to six weeks, via referral through pastoral channels.
This combination has a practical implication: families can expect a stepped model, early support in-school for emerging issues, with referral routes for more complex needs. That is the kind of structure that tends to reduce “grey areas” where concerns can otherwise drift between staff roles.
The arrangements for safeguarding are effective.
Extracurricular life at Malton is shaped by two things: timetable design that protects time for enrichment, and facilities that support high participation rather than a small elite.
The school’s extracurricular listing gives a helpful window into what is currently running, rather than generic claims. Examples include:
A student-led Current Affairs Club in the library
Club 32 for Year 7, framed as a space for board games and social connection
Revision club provision for older year groups
Practical creative work around drama and dance, including rehearsal schedules linked to the annual production, with “Chicago” referenced as the current show rehearsal focus in the published schedule
Formal observations also mention wider activities such as the Duke of Edinburgh’s Award, the European Space Agency Astro Pi Challenge, and coding. The evidence matters here because it indicates a blend of traditional enrichment (Duke of Edinburgh) and modern STEM-linked activity (Astro Pi), which suits students whose interests do not sit neatly in one box.
Trips are framed as curriculum-enriching rather than just “nice extras”. The inspection report gives concrete examples, York for urban land use change, London for economics, and battlefield visits connected to history. For students, the implication is that learning is periodically “re-contextualised” outside the classroom, which can be particularly valuable for engagement in subjects like geography, history, and economics.
Facilities are one of the school’s clearer differentiators, and the school provides specific, checkable detail.
On the academic side:
8 specialist science laboratories plus 4 prep rooms
A technology suite with CAD-CAM, a laser cutter, and 3D printing
A library relocation and expansion in 2024 into a former music block, creating a flexible space for teaching, workshops, and study, alongside a shift of music into the former library area in the East Wing with dedicated classrooms and practice rooms
On the sport side, the Malton Community Sports Centre is housed on site, with student priority access during the day. Facilities include 4 badminton courts, indoor cricket nets, a climbing wall, a trampolining facility, and a full-size floodlit 3G pitch used for football and all-weather hockey and rugby, plus outdoor pitches, an athletics track, and courts.
The implication for families is straightforward: students with a strong sport or performance interest can train and compete without the logistical burden that off-site facilities often create, and students without that focus still benefit from better PE and club capacity.
The school day begins at 8.40am, with the first lesson starting at 8.45am. The normal finish time is 3.15pm on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday, with a later finish of 4.25pm on Thursday due to the Personal Development Activity programme. Lessons run in 75 minute blocks, and the school states students are in school for 34 hours and 5 minutes per week.
Transport is clearly structured. For students who live out of catchment, the school operates 8 routes and sets tiered charges for 2025 to 2026: Zone A £450 per year, Zone B £525 per year, Zone C £600 per year. The school also flags that routes can have waiting lists and are re-planned each April.
For parents trying to assess feasibility, it is worth combining the school’s published transport approach with a distance check. The FindMySchool Map Search can help you sense-check travel assumptions and compare options if you are weighing different secondaries across Ryedale and neighbouring areas.
A-level outcomes versus sixth form experience. The sixth form was judged Outstanding in the most recent inspection, but A-level grade profiles sit below England averages used for this review. Students who need top A-level grades should choose subjects carefully and use taster days and guidance to validate fit early.
EBacc profile. EBacc grade 5+ outcomes are relatively low at 11.4%. Families who prioritise a strongly academic, EBacc-heavy pathway should look closely at option structures, subject support, and how the student responds to independent study expectations.
Consistency in lessons and behaviour. Formal observations highlight that connections between prior learning and new learning are not always reinforced, and that off-task behaviour is not always identified and corrected. This may matter more for students who are easily distracted or who need strong structure to keep pace.
Transport costs for out-of-catchment families. The school-operated transport offer is a practical benefit, but it comes with annual charges and routes can be full. Families relying on school transport should confirm availability early and plan a back-up option.
Malton School offers a clear, structured version of comprehensive education, with strong pastoral scaffolding, a deliberately protected personal development timetable, and facilities that support broad participation. It suits families who want a stable, locally rooted secondary with a genuine post-16 option, and students who will make active use of clubs, trips, and targeted support to build momentum through Key Stage 4 and into sixth form. The main question is fit: for highly academic students aiming for the very top A-level outcomes, subject choice, habits, and use of support will matter more than branding.
Yes, for many families it will feel like a strong, well-organised comprehensive with clear systems. The latest inspection judged the school Good overall, with the sixth form judged Outstanding. Academic results are mixed, so the best indicator is whether the curriculum, support, and enrichment match your child’s needs and motivation.
Applications are coordinated through North Yorkshire Council. For September 2026 entry, the deadline was 31 October 2025, with National Offer Day on 2 March 2026. The school’s published admission number is 150 places per year group intake.
Open evenings typically run in late September. For example, the school held an open evening on 25 September 2025 for Year 5 and Year 6 families. Dates can change each year, so it is important to check the school calendar for the latest schedule.
The school sets minimum entry requirements of 4 GCSEs at grade 4+ including English or Maths for vocational courses, and 5 GCSEs at grade 4+ including English and Maths for A-level courses. Some subjects have higher requirements.
Yes. The school sets out a layered pastoral structure including Heads of Year, Key Stage Directors, an NHS Wellbeing in Mind Team based in school for common emotional wellbeing difficulties, and access to an independent therapist via referral routes. Safeguarding arrangements are described as effective in formal observations.
Get in touch with the school directly
Disclaimer
Information on this page is compiled, analysed, and processed from publicly available sources including the Department for Education (DfE), Ofsted, the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI), the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests, and official school websites.
Our rankings, metrics, and assessments are derived from this data using our own methodologies and represent our independent analysis rather than official standings.
While we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee that all information is current, complete, or error-free. Data may change without notice, and schools and/or local authorities should be contacted directly to verify any details before making decisions.
FindMySchool does not endorse any particular school, and rankings reflect specific metrics rather than overall quality.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information provided. If you believe any information is inaccurate, please contact us.
