The FMS Inspection Score is FindMySchool's proprietary analysis based on official Ofsted and ISI inspection reports. It converts ratings into a standardised 1–10 scale for fair comparison across all schools in England.
Disclaimer: The FMS Inspection Score is an independent analysis by FindMySchool. It is not endorsed by or affiliated with Ofsted or ISI. Always refer to the official Ofsted or ISI report for the full picture of a school’s inspection outcome.
Reception mornings start early here, and the timetable tells you a lot about the school’s priorities. Early Years runs in clear sessions, the main school day is structured, and Year 6 has its own earlier start time, a small but revealing detail about how the academy manages readiness and responsibility.
The most recent Ofsted inspection (24 and 25 September 2024, published 12 November 2024) graded the school Good across the main judgements, with Early Years provision graded Outstanding. Safeguarding was found to be effective.
Academically, the published 2024 Key Stage 2 outcomes show 74% reaching the expected standard in reading, writing and mathematics, above the England average of 62%. The scaled scores sit above England averages too, with reading at 102, mathematics at 104, and grammar, punctuation and spelling at 104.
The school’s public language is unusually specific about behaviour and learning habits. Pupils are expected to be “5 Star Learners”, with the REBELS framework setting out what that looks like in practice: Respect, Empower, Believe, Enlighten, Learn, Succeed. The emphasis is on consistency and on adults modelling expectations, with the explicit idea that behaviour is a form of communication.
Ofsted’s description of daily life reinforces the same picture. Routines are presented as the engine of calm, especially in the early years, and the school is explicit about having high expectations for behaviour. The inspection also notes deliberate provision for different kinds of breaktime experiences, including calmer spaces for pupils who prefer reading or board games.
The house system is another piece of culture-building that is more developed than many primaries. House teams are named after local street names, Millbrook, Spencerfield, Colmore and Rainsford, and the house points system is used for behaviour, collaboration and participation. Even the daily “wake up & boogie” is tied into points, a small example of how the academy turns routines into shared identity.
Leadership is clearly identified in official sources. The principal is Helen Steele.
(An official start date is not consistently published in the sources above, so it is better to treat tenure as unconfirmed rather than guess.)
For a primary academy, the most useful public benchmark is Key Stage 2, because it combines attainment and readiness for secondary transition.
In 2024, 74% of pupils reached the expected standard in reading, writing and mathematics combined. The England average is 62%, so the academy is ahead on this headline measure.
Scaled scores offer a finer signal than a single threshold. The academy’s 2024 averages were:
Reading: 102
Mathematics: 104
Grammar, punctuation and spelling: 104
At the higher standard in reading, writing and mathematics combined, 16% achieved the higher standard, compared with the England average of 8%. That is a meaningful difference for families with pupils who thrive on stretch.
On the FindMySchool ranking (based on official performance data), the school is ranked 10,584th in England for primary outcomes and 41st in Middlesbrough. This position sits in the lower performance band nationally (outside the 25th to 60th percentile middle range), even though the 2024 expected-standard headline is above the England average. The practical takeaway is that outcomes look stronger on the threshold measure than on the composite ranking signal, so parents comparing schools should look at both.
A sensible way to use this is to compare nearby schools on FindMySchool’s Local Hub comparison tools, rather than relying on a single headline figure in isolation.
England ranks and key metrics (where available)
Reading, Writing & Maths
74%
% of pupils achieving expected standard
The inspection report is clear about what the school sees as its academic engine: early reading. Reading is described as being central to the curriculum, with tightly matched books to the sounds pupils are learning, and rapid identification of gaps followed by targeted catch-up support. Daily practice is explicitly part of the model, and the expected outcome is fluent, accurate reading as pupils move through the school.
In Early Years, the picture is similarly structured. The inspection describes high expectations, careful curriculum design, and strong adaptation of learning opportunities so barriers to achievement are reduced, including for children with additional needs. The result described is confidence and independence developing quickly in Reception.
The main development priorities are also worth noting because they indicate where the school is still bedding things in. Ofsted notes that some curriculum areas have been introduced relatively recently, and that in some subjects pupils do not always have the prior knowledge needed for new content to land well. Oracy is another explicit priority, with inspectors stating that many pupils struggle to explain their thinking, and the school is expected to continue prioritising oracy and classroom discussion.
For parents, this matters because it signals a school that is actively refining curriculum sequencing and talk-rich teaching, rather than assuming consistency is already locked across every subject.
As a Middlesbrough primary, the main transition point is Year 6 to Year 7, typically through the local authority’s secondary admissions process.
The school itself does not publish a single “feeder” pathway in the official sources used here, so it is best to treat secondary destinations as driven by home address, family preference, and Middlesbrough’s admissions arrangements. In practical terms, families considering Caldicotes should shortlist likely secondaries early and track both travel time and admissions criteria.
The strongest preparation signal in the published evidence is literacy. A school that puts daily reading practice, decodable matching, and rapid intervention at the centre of teaching is generally prioritising the skill that most reliably supports secondary access across all subjects.
Caldicotes is a state-funded academy, so there are no tuition fees. Entry is primarily through Reception, with nursery also available for younger children.
The latest available admissions figures show 36 applications for 26 offers, and the entry route is marked as oversubscribed. That roughly equates to about 1.38 applications per place offered, which suggests some competition without the extreme pressure seen in very tight urban catchments.
Applications open: mid November 2025 (application packs sent and online portal opens)
National closing date: 15 January 2026
National offer day: 16 April 2026
In the Middlesbrough admissions guide, the academy’s published admission number (PAN) is 30 for Reception. If oversubscribed, priority includes looked-after and previously looked-after children, siblings, and other criteria, with an admission zone referenced in the academy’s own nursery admissions information.
. Families who want to evaluate chances should use FindMySchool’s Map Search to check their exact distance and then cross-check Middlesbrough’s coordinated admissions documentation for the current year.
100%
1st preference success rate
25 of 25 first-choice applicants received an offer
Places
26
Offers
26
Applications
36
Two features stand out in the public evidence.
First, there is a deliberate emphasis on pupils feeling cared for, with Ofsted reporting that pupils know teachers care about them and expect them to try hard. That combination, warmth plus expectation, is often what parents mean when they say a school “feels safe but purposeful”.
Second, behaviour is treated as something to be actively taught and supported, not simply enforced. The school frames behaviour as communication, and Ofsted notes that adults support pupils who need extra help managing behaviour. The CLAP approach is specifically mentioned as a recent change designed to improve breaktimes, alongside calm spaces for pupils who prefer quieter activities.
Safeguarding is reported as effective in the most recent inspection.
The academy’s enrichment is easiest to evidence through what is explicitly described in official sources, rather than generic claims.
A clear example is the school’s approach to break and lunchtimes. CLAP, Caldicotes Learning and Play, is designed to make play purposeful and exciting, while also creating calmer options such as reading or board games for pupils who prefer them. The implication is that the school is trying to reduce low-level conflict by offering structured choices, not just supervising a single playground experience.
Trips and experiences are also part of the picture. Ofsted notes opportunities such as visits to the beach and the theatre, sports and adventurous activities, and even a visit to the Houses of Parliament. These are useful signals for parents weighing cultural enrichment, particularly in a school serving a local community where access to wider experiences can vary widely between households.
Within-school culture-building is more explicit than many primaries, through the house team structure and house points. With named houses, visible colours, and regular points allocation, pupils get a steady drumbeat of shared goals and recognition. For some children, that is motivating and confidence-building. For others, especially those who dislike competition, parents may want to ask how the system is managed to keep it inclusive.
Wraparound enrichment is more difficult to describe precisely because the after-school clubs page is presented in a generic template format rather than listing specific clubs and times.
If clubs are a key decision factor, ask the school for the current term’s club list.
Early Years morning session: 08:30 to 11:30
Early Years afternoon session: 12:15 to 15:15
Reception to Year 5: 08:40 to 15:10
Year 6: 08:15 to 15:10
Breakfast club runs from 8am in the main school building. The published cost is £2.50 per week, and it is positioned for working families or those accessing higher education, with breakfast provided (cereals, toast, drink).
The academy publishes term dates and professional development days, useful for planning childcare and work commitments.
The school sits in Acklam, Middlesbrough. Travel patterns for this area typically involve walking, local bus routes, and short car drop-offs. Parking and drop-off arrangements are not detailed in the sources above, so families should confirm practicalities directly with the school, particularly if they expect to use wraparound care.
National ranking signal is modest. The FindMySchool primary ranking places the school at 10,584th in England, which sits below the middle performance band nationally, even though 2024 expected-standard outcomes are above England average. Families should review multiple measures before drawing conclusions.
Curriculum consistency is still bedding in for some subjects. Ofsted notes that some subject curriculums are relatively new, and pupils do not always have the prior knowledge required for new content to be introduced successfully. Ask how curriculum sequencing is being strengthened, especially outside English and mathematics.
Oracy is an explicit development priority. Inspectors highlight that many pupils struggle to explain their thinking, and the school is expected to prioritise oracy across the curriculum. This can be a positive sign of self-awareness, but parents of pupils with speech and language needs may want to ask what targeted support looks like.
After-school club detail is not clearly published. The after-school clubs page uses a template structure without specific club listings or times. If wraparound and clubs are essential, request the current schedule.
Caldicotes Primary Academy looks like a school that invests heavily in routines, early reading, and a calm learning climate, with an Early Years phase that stands out strongly in the most recent inspection evidence. Academic outcomes at Key Stage 2 are above England average on the expected-standard headline, while the wider ranking signal suggests results are more mixed on composite measures.
Who it suits: families who want clear behavioural expectations, a strong reading-led approach, and an Early Years experience that has been externally recognised as a strength. The main decision work is around fit, particularly how the curriculum is developing beyond the most established subjects, and how well the house-point culture suits your child.
The most recent Ofsted inspection (September 2024) graded the school Good across the main judgements, with Early Years provision graded Outstanding. Safeguarding was found to be effective. Key Stage 2 outcomes in 2024 were above the England average on the expected-standard headline measure.
The academy references an admission zone in its admissions information, and Middlesbrough coordinates primary admissions on a borough-wide timetable. The most reliable approach is to check Middlesbrough’s current admissions guide and confirm how the academy applies distance and zone criteria when oversubscribed.
Yes. The school has nursery provision, and its published information describes Early Years sessions and how children transition into nursery and then into Reception. Nursery attendance does not guarantee a Reception place, so families still need to apply through the normal Reception admissions route.
For Middlesbrough primary admissions, the national closing date is 15 January 2026, with offers released on 16 April 2026. Families should apply through the local authority’s coordinated process.
Yes. Breakfast club runs from 8am. The published cost is £2.50 per week and includes breakfast items such as cereals and toast.
Get in touch with the school directly
Disclaimer
Information on this page is compiled, analysed, and processed from publicly available sources including the Department for Education (DfE), Ofsted, the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI), the Universities of Oxford and Cambridge, Freedom of Information (FOI) requests, and official school websites.
Our rankings, metrics, and assessments are derived from this data using our own methodologies and represent our independent analysis rather than official standings.
While we strive for accuracy, we cannot guarantee that all information is current, complete, or error-free. Data may change without notice, and schools and/or local authorities should be contacted directly to verify any details before making decisions.
FindMySchool does not endorse any particular school, and rankings reflect specific metrics rather than overall quality.
To the fullest extent permitted by law, we accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on information provided. If you believe any information is inaccurate, please contact us.
