Melsonby Methodist Primary School Review 2026: Small village primary, strong federation links, clear values

Recent key stage 2 performance data is not presented for this school, so it is not possible to provide secure, like for like comparisons to England averages here.

What can be said with confidence is that external evaluation continues to rate the quality of education positively. The latest inspection (8 and 9 October 2024) graded all key judgement areas as Good, including early years provision.

Where this matters for families is the “why” behind the grade. The October 2024 report describes high expectations for pupils, and highlights that staff know pupils well enough to personalise learning and put support in quickly when pupils fall behind. This is a common advantage of very small schools, when systems are tight and staffing is stable.

Early reading is clearly a priority. The October 2024 inspection describes a well embedded phonics scheme, consistent routines, and staff expertise in teaching early reading. Pupils who need extra support to build fluency receive it and catch up quickly, and older pupils have regular guided reading alongside access to a wide range of quality texts.

Mathematics is also described as coherently sequenced, with staff addressing misconceptions quickly and using strong subject knowledge to keep pupils moving forward. For pupils with special educational needs and or disabilities (SEND), the inspection describes support that enables them to achieve in line with their peers within mathematics lessons.

In a small, mixed-age context, curriculum design becomes more complex. The October 2024 report notes that the wider curriculum has had recent change, and that it is too early to see full impact. It also identifies an improvement point, the need for more systematic use of assessment information in some subjects so gaps are identified and addressed before moving on. This is useful for parents because it is specific, it points to the kind of teaching refinement the school is working on, rather than a broad concern about standards.

For a village primary, transition is often shaped by geography and transport as much as preference. The federation newsletters show Year 6 engagement with Richmond School, including an open evening entry and activities such as a journalism day hosted there.

That does not mean every pupil moves to the same secondary, but it is a practical indicator of established links and a clear awareness of the next step. The confidence building aspect is also flagged in the October 2024 inspection, which notes that pupils gain confidence and are ready for the next stage of their education.

Admissions are managed by North Yorkshire Council rather than directly by the school, for both Reception entry and in year moves.

For Reception entry in September 2026, North Yorkshire Council states that the application round opens on 12 October 2025 and closes on 15 January 2026, with a final date of 22 February 2026 for changes or late applications before National Offer Day. National Offer Day for primary is 16 April 2026.

Demand for Reception places is not described as intense in the most recent published figures available with 6 applications and 6 offers recorded, alongside an “undersubscribed” status. For many families this will be reassuring, it suggests that living in the immediate village area is not the only route to a place, although circumstances can change year to year.

Because the school is a voluntary controlled Methodist school, families should still read the local authority’s admission arrangements and the school’s own admissions guidance carefully, particularly if there are criteria linked to siblings, distance, or exceptional medical or social reasons, and ensure evidence is submitted by the stated deadlines.

A practical tip for families comparing options is to use FindMySchool’s Map Search to sense check travel time and daily logistics from your front door, especially in a rural area where a short distance can still mean a longer journey.

The strongest pastoral advantage here is the combination of small numbers and clear, values-based culture. The October 2024 inspection describes a calm atmosphere, pupils behaving well at social times as well as in lessons, and staff support for families who need help with attendance.

The denominational inspection adds detail about wellbeing structures, describing leadership choices that prioritise staff wellbeing and an extremely caring culture, alongside reflective spaces that give pupils moments of stillness and a place to share worries.

On safeguarding, the October 2024 inspection states that safeguarding arrangements are effective.

Extracurricular breadth can be hard for very small schools, unless it is planned deliberately. Two mechanisms stand out.

First, the school uses federation structures to widen experiences, including weekly Federation Fridays and a federation school council that meets weekly.

Second, enrichment is described as active and practical. The October 2024 inspection mentions after-school clubs including crafts and cooking, and also references residential trips to London and Edinburgh, a strong offer for a village primary because it expands pupils’ horizons beyond their immediate community.

Federation newsletters also show a rolling calendar of enrichment such as Forest School days and themed whole-school activities, including community and church-linked events.

The school day information published on the federation site states that doors open at 8.40am, with the school day running from 8.45am to 3.15pm (32.5 hours per week). Morning break is 10.30am to 10.45am, lunch is 12.00 noon to 1.00pm, and an afternoon break is listed for Foundation and key stage 1.

The October 2024 inspection report states that the school runs its own wraparound care clubs, and the staff list includes a named breakfast club lead, but the published pages do not clearly set out timings and booking arrangements in one place. Parents who need regular wraparound care should ask directly about days, staffing, pick up times, and whether provision is term-time only.

For transport, this is a rural setting and daily travel tends to be shaped by village routes and family logistics. Families should check North Yorkshire Council’s travel guidance and confirm any eligibility based on distance and age.

• Very small cohort sizes. Small numbers can be a major strength for personalised support, but some children want a larger friendship group day to day. Federation activity helps broaden the peer group, but it is still worth thinking about your child’s social preferences.

• Curriculum changes still bedding in. The October 2024 inspection notes that parts of the wider curriculum are recent, and that assessment practice in some subjects needs to become more systematic. Families who prioritise the foundation subjects should ask how those improvements are being implemented.

• Wraparound care specifics. Wraparound clubs are referenced in official material, but families who rely on early drop-off or later pick-up should confirm exact hours, costs, and availability.

• Faith character is real. Collective worship and a Christian vision are central features, including links with local church life. Families who prefer a fully secular approach should weigh whether this is the right fit.

Melsonby Methodist Primary School suits families who want a small, village-based primary with a clear values framework, strong relationships, and the kind of individual attention that is hard to replicate in larger settings. Federation links matter here, they widen social experience and opportunities while keeping the benefits of small class sizes. The main question for families is fit, whether your child will thrive in a small cohort, and whether the Methodist character and worship rhythm feel aligned with your expectations.