St Mary’s Catholic Primary School, Sunderland Review 2026: Elite KS2 Outcomes, Strong Catholic Ethos

A Catholic primary where behaviour, curriculum coherence, and academic outcomes all point in the same direction. St Mary’s serves families in Ashbrooke and beyond, with a published admission number of 60 for Reception entry and demand that outstrips supply. The current headteacher, Mr Martin Clephane, has led the school since September 2019, and the most recent Ofsted visit (December 2024, published January 2025) described a calm, purposeful place where pupils achieve highly and safeguarding is effective.

Three simple rules shape daily routines: be kind, be safe, believe. It is a helpful lens for understanding the feel of the school, because it links conduct to identity rather than to sanctions. Pupils are expected to be courteous and to take responsibility for each other, with older pupils positioned as role models rather than informal enforcers.

Catholic life is not an optional add-on. The school’s mission and parish links are presented as part of its core purpose, and the admissions policy makes clear that Catholic doctrine and practice are intended to permeate daily school life, even while welcoming applications from families of all faiths and none. This matters for fit. Families seeking a faith-led primary, with prayer, liturgy, and service threaded through school culture, tend to find the tone reassuring and consistent.

Leadership stability is a key part of the recent story. Mr Martin Clephane is listed as headteacher on the school’s own staff information and on Get Information About Schools, and diocesan documentation refers to a new permanent headteacher appointed for September 2019, aligning with his tenure.

A final distinctive note is the way the school describes its curriculum intent. The BREW framework (Belief, Rights, Environment, Wellbeing) is positioned as a practical driver, not a poster slogan, shaping enrichment and how pupils are taught to think about the wider world.

The headline is that this is an exceptionally high-performing primary by KS2 measures.

In 2024, 94% of pupils met the expected standard in reading, writing and maths combined. That is well above the England average of 62%. At the higher standard, 46% reached greater depth in reading, writing and maths, compared to 8% across England. Reading and maths scaled scores were both 110, and grammar, punctuation and spelling was 113, all notably above typical national benchmarks.

FindMySchool’s rankings place the school 177th in England for primary outcomes, and 1st in Sunderland. That sits among the highest-performing in England (top 2%). (FindMySchool ranking based on official data.)

What this means in practice is that pupils are not merely keeping up, they are leaving Year 6 with strong fundamentals and a large proportion operating comfortably above age-related expectations. For families thinking about long-term trajectory, it reduces the likelihood that a child will need catch-up support later, and it can make selective or high-demand secondary pathways feel more realistic, if that is a family goal.

Curriculum design is unusually explicit for a primary. The school frames learning through BREW, and that has two practical effects for pupils.

First, it encourages pupils to make connections across subjects. The most recent inspection noted pupils applying learning from English, history, geography, art and other areas to talk with depth about topics such as world conflict and moral dilemmas. Second, it supports a personal development offer that is not separated from classroom learning, with educational visits and visitors used to build knowledge, character, and vocabulary rather than simply to entertain.

Early reading also has a clear place in the school’s approach. From the early years, adults are described as modelling language and building children’s confidence in communication, with secure foundations in phonics and number developing over time. This is the kind of wording that usually correlates with structured teaching, consistent routines, and a high expectation that all children will read fluently, not just those who arrive already confident.

As a primary with nursery provision, the school has two key transitions to consider: Nursery to Reception, then Year 6 to secondary.

Nursery to Reception

The admissions policy is clear that attendance at the nursery does not automatically guarantee a Reception place. Families using nursery as a route into the main school still need to apply through the normal local authority process.

The prospectus also sets out separate nursery session times, which signals that early years is treated as a distinct phase with its own rhythm, rather than a simple holding pen before “real school” begins.

Year 6 to secondary

The school does not publish a destination list of which secondaries pupils move on to. In Sunderland, families apply for secondary places through the local authority’s coordinated system, and choices typically include a mix of Catholic and non-faith secondaries depending on preference, travel, and admissions criteria.

For context, the school sits within Bishop Chadwick Catholic Education Trust, which also includes local secondary provision such as St Aidan’s Catholic Academy. Proximity and trust membership alone do not determine transfer, but they do give Catholic families a clear pathway to explore.

Parents comparing options can use FindMySchool’s Local Hub and Comparison Tool to look at likely secondary destinations side-by-side on results, context, and admissions signals.

Entry is competitive. For Reception entry, the school received 103 applications for 59 offers in the latest available admissions snapshot, which equates to around 1.75 applications per place, and the school is recorded as oversubscribed.

St Mary’s is its own admissions authority via the trust, but Sunderland City Council coordinates the application process. For September 2026 entry, the council application window runs from 29 September 2025 to 15 January 2026, with National Offer Day on 16 April 2026.

Because this is a Catholic school, oversubscription rules prioritise Catholic children first (including parish residency), then other groups, with distance used as the tie-breaker within categories when needed. Evidence requirements matter here. The admissions policy indicates that supporting documents, such as baptismal evidence where relevant, should be supplied at the point of application to avoid an application being placed in a lower priority category.

A practical planning point for families is to treat St Mary’s as an “apply and also plan a back-up” option. Oversubscription in primaries can fluctuate year to year depending on cohort size and local movement, so families should build a realistic list rather than relying on a single outcome.

Safeguarding arrangements are described as effective, and the school positions safeguarding as a priority in its parent-facing information, with trained staff and clear internal roles.

Wellbeing is also built into the school’s language around curriculum intent, through the BREW framework and a wider emphasis on pupils developing emotionally as well as academically. In practical terms, this often shows up in how behaviour is managed: clear routines, consistent expectations, and pupils who can explain what safe choices look like.

For Catholic families, the pastoral picture is typically strengthened by the community dimension, parish links, service, and shared rituals that can help younger pupils feel known and supported.

This is a school that names its enrichment clearly, which usually correlates with consistent delivery rather than a rotating list of vague clubs.

Forest School is offered from Nursery through to Year 6, described as a structured outdoor education experience focused on confidence, teamwork, resilience, and learning in a natural environment. The implication for families is that outdoor learning is not limited to a single year group or a one-off theme week, it is positioned as a steady part of school life, including for the youngest children.

Mini Vinnies is another strong example of Catholic life translating into action. The group sits within the Society of St Vincent de Paul and is aimed at Years 3 and 4, with pupils organising practical initiatives such as a school foodbank rota, charity activity around Advent and Lent, and writing to parishioners who are housebound. The implication is a school that expects children to practise service, not just learn about it, and that gives them age-appropriate responsibility.

Gardening Club is presented as a whole-school team model, with two children from each year group (Year 1 to Year 6) involved in growing and caring for plants and vegetables, supported by the school’s grounds and Forest School space. The benefit is twofold: it builds practical skills and it reinforces the school’s “Environment” strand within BREW through lived experience.

There is also a practical wraparound offer that supports working families, with breakfast and after-school provision that includes food and structured supervision.

The main school day runs 9:00am to 3:30pm, with classroom doors opening from 8:45am. Nursery operates separate morning and afternoon sessions.

Wraparound care is available via a Breakfast Club (7:30am to 8:45am) and an After-School Club (3:30pm to 5:30pm) for Reception to Year 6, with published session prices.

Parking close to the school is described as difficult, with the school asking families to walk where possible and to park considerately to protect neighbours’ access and pedestrian safety.

• Competition for places. With the school oversubscribed and roughly 1.75 applications per place in the latest snapshot, admission is not something to assume. Families should plan alternatives alongside an application.

• Catholic criteria really matter. The admissions framework prioritises Catholic children, including parish links, and supporting evidence can affect priority. Families who are not Catholic can apply, but should read the criteria carefully and plan realistically.

• Nursery is not a guaranteed route into Reception. Even if a child attends the nursery, Reception entry still requires the standard application process, and a place is not automatic.

• Wraparound hours end at 5:30pm. For some working patterns, that will be ideal; for others, it may require additional arrangements.

St Mary’s Catholic Primary School, Sunderland combines very high KS2 outcomes with a clear Catholic identity and a curriculum structure that aims to connect learning, character, and community service. It suits families who want a faith-shaped education, strong behaviour norms, and academic results that are among the strongest in England for primaries. The limiting factor is admission, so the best approach is to apply with a back-up plan and to treat evidence requirements as mission-critical.